Biological Trace Element Research
November 2011
Ahmad Movahedian Attar, Azam Kharkhaneh, Masoud Etemadifar, Kiandokht Keyhanian, Vahid Davoudi & Mohammad Saadatnia
Abstract
Exposure to heavy metals has been associated to a higher incidence of multiple sclerosis. In this work, we present a possible relationship between serum mercury levels and development of multiple sclerosis in Isfahan, the third largest city in Iran. Seventy-four patients affected by multiple sclerosis were retrieved from multiple sclerosis (MS) clinic in Isfahan, Iran. By matching sex and age, 74 healthy volunteers were chosen as control group.
Blood samples were collected and serum mercury content was determined. Serum mercury level in MS patients was significantly higher than controls (9.6±10.17 vs. 5.7±8.6, P=0.037). Concerning all MS patients, serum mercury value was significantly higher than the mercury concentration founded in control subjects {odd ratio: 2.39 (CI, 1.96– 2.94), P=0.00}.
Serum mercury level is higher in MS patients with odd ratio equal to 2.39 compared with healthy individuals.
It may reveal that high mercury levels in serum might help MS development in susceptible individuals.
More studies with larger sample size are needed to confirm this hypothesis.
Introduction
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an inflammatory demyelinating disorder of the central nervous system (CNS) [1]. Although genetic and immunological factors have been strongly mentioned to be associated with MS pathogenesis, the ultimate etiology of MS remains uncertain [2, 3]. Apparently, both genetics and environmental factors are important in pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis [4]. Recently, environmental factors such as pathogens and chemicals (toxic elements) have been suggested to play a significant role in MS pathogenesis. Moreover, exposure to heavy metals has been associated to a higher incidence of multiple sclerosis [5–8].
Among all, mercury is assumed to be one of the most toxic within nonradioactive elements. Dietary use of predatory fish is considered to be the most frequent resource of organic mercury exposure [9]. Moreover, mercury and its derivatives have been widely used in different products including antiparasitics, antiseptics, dental amalgams, medical equipment, and beauty creams.
Subsequent to growing industrial applications of mercury, its environmental level is estimated to increase more than threefold in the past century [10, 11]. Casualties who exposed to mass exposure in Japan during 1950–1960 along with victims in Iraq through 1971–1972, were related to mercury-contaminated fish and fungicide in seed grains, respectively. This highlights the role of mercury as an important neurotoxicant [12, 13]. Meanwhile, there are many unsubstantiated claims that chronic mercury poisoning causes neurological diseases and behavioral problems.
MS is also reported to be due to chronic mercury intoxication. Review of recent literature claims that mercury used in dental amalgams may lead to nephrotoxicity, neurobehavioral changes, autoimmunity, and oxidative stress [14–16].
Dental amalgam is an alloy which contains about 50% mercury and is frequently used in dentistry as a tooth-filling material [11, 17]. There are many studies which have shown that dental amalgams may contribute in pathogenesis of various tissue burdens, particularly within CNS, kidneys, and certain glands [12]. Meanwhile, in 1986, a correlation between multiple sclerosis and chronic exposure to mercury via dental amalgam fillings was reported [18].
Due to high incidence of multiple sclerosis and also industrial pollutions in Isfahan, we studied the possible relation between serum mercury level and development of MS in Isfahan that is the third largest city of Iran.
Discussion
Serum mercury level in healthy individuals and MS patients differed significantly. This difference was also observed in male and females. Additionally, abnormal high level of mercury was observed to be more in MS patients, revealing that high amounts of mercury in serum could be a factor that increases susceptibility of individuals to multiple sclerosis.
The global prevalence of MS is increasing and is expected to be approximately 3.6/100,000 person-years in women and 2.0/100 000 person-years in men, which reveals the female preponderance [22]. Nevertheless, MS course is more benign in females and younger individuals [23]. Males are older at onset and are susceptible for having more progressive disease course and a more rapid progression of the disease [24].
Here, in this study, we could not find any association between serum mercury level and different sex, so it appears that mercury alone may not contribute to the different susceptibility of sexes in developing MS.
However, further studies are needed to evaluate the association between mercury exposure and different susceptibility of sexes and also varied severity in the course of MS.
Usual values for whole blood mercury are less than 6 μg/L; however, taking diets rich in fish might cause elevated mercury levels [9]. Mercury has a short half-life in the blood; therefore, if the exposure is chronic, obtaining urine levels in 24-h collections is more accurate [9]. Further researches with larger sample and different method for mercury evaluations are needed to establish the role of such toxic element in pathogenesis of MS.
Mercury is a potent toxin which affects the basic functions of the cell, through binding strongly with sulfhydryl and selenohydryl groups on albumin molecules in cell membranes, receptors and intracellular signal links, and by modifying the tertiary structure.
One popular hypothesis that is frequently propounded in the literature suggests mercury to be toxic due to inducing production of free radicals and modifying the redox potential of the cell [25]. Otherwise, low concentrations of mercury may provoke phosphorylation and consequently intracellular signaling [26].
Mercury also inhibits the development of cytoskeleton structure in nerve cells and breaks it down [27]. Tschudi et al. studied the incidence of apoptosis within cultures of fetal rat brain and found that mercury speeds up the spontaneous apoptosis in immature cultures, especially astrocytes [28].
In another survey, Shenker et al. demonstrated that mercury is able to induce an apoptotic cascade in human T lymphocytes [29].
Duxbury et al. have also shown that mercury is toxic for oligodendroglial cells and human oligodendroglial cell line MO3.13. They choose this cell line to model the loss of oligodendrocytes occurring through episodes of MS. They show that damages are caused by specially an apoptotic manner, when exposed to low concentration of Hgcl2 [30]. On the other hand, MS is a degenerative disease of the central nervous system affecting the oligodendroglial components of the nerve.
The pathological hallmark of MS is the plaque, a well-demarcated gray or pink lesion, characterized histologically by complete myelin loss, an absence of oligodendrocytes and relative sparing of axons. Oligodendrocytes are destroyed as an early event during the disease pathogenesis and are also found to be distressed in chronic lesions [31].
Although several observations were made to explain the possible role of mercury in MS etiology, the exact pathogenesis is still unclear. Circumstantial evidence includes empirical observations in which accidentally ingested mercury produces a set of symptoms similar to those observed in MS patients [32]. Dental amalgam fillings containing mercury have been suggested as a possible risk factor for MS as well [15].
Bangsi et al. [33] counted the number of amalgam restorations and found a higher amount of dental amalgams in MS patients. Yet, McGrother CW et al., found no relationship between the high levels of mercury in blood and urine as well as the raised number of amalgam fillings, and susceptibility to multiple sclerosis [16]. After all, Etminan et al., within a meta-analysis, found a slight, non-statistically significant increase of MS development while dental amalgams are used [11].
However, we showed the association between mercury blood level and MS, with odd ratio equal to 2.39 (2.94– 1.94). Nevertheless, further complementary observations are needed to uncover the inter-relationship between MS and mercury as well as other heavy metals within CSF, blood, and urine samples.
In conclusion, serum mercury level is higher in MS patients with odd ratio equal to 2.39 compared with healthy individuals, revealing that high amounts of mercury in serum might be a factor that increases susceptibility to multiple sclerosis. More studies with larger sample size are needed to confirm this hypothesis.
